The most complete player of all-time?

Discussion in 'The Beautiful Game' started by y.o.n.k.o, Jan 28, 2011.

  1. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024



    ....








    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerd_Müller






    https://www.rsssf.org/players/pgmuellerdata.html






    ....

    ...
    All Official Matches

    Type Period Matches Goals
    South Germany Championship (Youth) 1962-63 3 2
    Amateur League 1963-64 31 51
    Reserve Team Championship 1964/65 3 2
    Regionalliga Süd (2nd level) 1964/65 26 33
    Promotion Playoff 1965 6 6
    Bundesliga 1965-79 427 365
    NASL (USA) 1979-81 80 40
    DFB-Pokal 1964-78 64 80
    Liga-Pokal 1972 5 12
    International Cups 1966-77 79 70
    Intertoto Cup 1978 6 5
    Germany National Team 1966-74 62 68
    Germany U-23 Team 1966 1 1
    Total 1962-81 793 735





    ...
    ..
    [1] Müllers 1000th goal was the winner in the World Cup final on July 7, 1974.
    [2] Müllers farewell match.

    NB: the following matches and goals have not been taken into account:

    1) company football team „Bremshey“ (summer 1964), where Müller worked;
    reason: very low level of competition (companies cup) and missing
    documentation on Müllers appearances and goals;
    2) indoor football;
    3) Müllers goals in penalty shoot-outs (1 in European Cup and 5 in
    friendly tournaments);
    4) youth team TSV Nördlingen (1960-1963, during which time Müller scored
    over 500 goals, including over 400 goals in official matches).

    All Official Matches

    Type Period Matches Goals
    South Germany Championship (Youth) 1962-63 3 2
    Amateur League 1963-64 31 51
    Reserve Team Championship 1964/65 3 2
    Regionalliga Süd (2nd level) 1964/65 26 33
    Promotion Playoff 1965 6 6
    Bundesliga 1965-79 427 365
    NASL (USA) 1979-81 80 40
    DFB-Pokal 1964-78 64 80
    Liga-Pokal 1972 5 12
    International Cups 1966-77 79 70
    Intertoto Cup 1978 6 5
    Germany National Team 1966-74 62 68
    Germany U-23 Team 1966 1 1
    Total 1962-81 793 735

    All Clubs

    Club Period Official Other Total
    1. Bavaria Youth Team 1962-63 3 2 3 2
    2. TSV 1861 Nördlingen 1963-64 31 51 2 7 33 58
    3. FC Bayern 1964-79,83 616 573 386[1] 684 1002[2] 1257
    4. FC Bayern Combineds [3] 1966,73 2 [1] 2 2 2
    5. Germany National Teams 1966-74 63 69 8 20 71 89
    6. FIFA / UEFA Selection 1971-73 5 2 5 2
    7. Benefit Matches 1965-80 3 1 3 1
    8. Fort Lauderdale Strikers 1979-81 80 40 27 32 107 72

    Total 793 735 433 748 1226 1483



    .....
     
  2. Isaías Silva Serafim

    Real Madrid
    Brazil
    Dec 2, 2021
    Nat'l Team:
    Brazil
    What's exactly your point? I mean, I know Gerd Muller's goalscoring record is impressive no matter what is the cutoff but doesn't make much sense for you to mention this when comparing him to a sweeper. Beckenbauer's contributions weren't limited to scoring goals
     
    Wiliam Felipe Gracek repped this.
  3. Letmepost

    Letmepost Member

    Arsenal
    South Korea
    Apr 11, 2023
    If current analytics is guilty of somewhat overstating the pragmatic importance of being an entertaining and interesting player in possession of the ball, I wouldn't see why that can't be also true for the past. The eye-test must have been even more emphasized, especially due to the limited statistics available.

    Regardless of your actual level of pragmatic worth, I think it is always better for personal recognition and accolades to be an exciting player for the spectator whilst you have the ball at your feet.

    Uli Hoeneß (who seems to be a pacy dribbling type of player) seems to be higher rated in terms of seasonal average ratings by Kicker, than Gerd Muller. There does seem to be a stylistic preference, that would probably count against someone like Gerd Muller.

    I think it is one thing to be pragmatically effective, and another to be worthy of adulation. Of course, if possible, a player should aim for both. If given the choice of one, I always prefer the one with greater pragmatic value, even if I hate watching him. I personally do not think the Kicker ratings are accurate reflections of the pragmatic value Gerd Muller brought to his team, from the little I've seen of him.

    It would probably be accurate that with the ball at his feet, Gerd Muller was not even the best in his position within the Bundesliga for that specific time-frame. However, while other legendary Bundesliga attackers like Karl-Heinz Rummenigge probably produce 10 times the amount of excitement and dopamine hits for the spectator when he gets the ball compared to Gerd Muller (and as such probably gets rewarded by magazines and pundits), I'm not sure if people will start picking the usual highest rated players by Kicker if their entire life savings were on the line if we strictly talk about results and pragmatic valuation of the players.

    I'm too uneducated about Gerd Muller to comment without talking out of my ass, but I do have some reservations about the precise measurement of pragmatic worth, if we use Kicker ratings as the standard.
     
    Wiliam Felipe Gracek repped this.
  4. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    My Point ... is :


    BORN DECISION MAKING POWER ... on the bigger Matches ... is the most important thing for me ...




    YOU CAN'T LEARN THAT , YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT .. !



    AND

    STRONGER PERSONALITY ARE NOT FOR SALE ..ON THE SQUARE !



    " YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT .. ! "



    If YOU DON'T HAVE IT .. !


    Vira tipo um Ronaldinho ..Gaucho da vida ... Muito Talento em Habilidades .. na parte de Skills ....


    Mas na hora da Decisão ...do Jogo Grande...

    Não decide praticamente nada por elemesmo .. na Carreira ..

    Precisa do Belletti ... Larsson ..Eto'o ... Rivaldo .. Ronaldo Nazario ..
    para decidir pra ele ...

    ..Não estou falando com isto que era o mesmo caso do Franz Beckenbauer ...

    Beckenbauer .. dava bastante Assistencias ... e Pre_assistencias ... nas partidas que vi dele jogando ..


    Mas estou ..querendo dizer que Gerd Muller é altamente sub-estimado pra caramba ...


    Gerd Muller em 1970-71 ... foi o lider de Assistencias .." 13 " ..da Bundesliga ...

    por exemplo ..ficou .. há frente .. de Beckenbauer ..Overath ..Netzer ...etc ..



    FRanz Beckenbauer foi o lider em Assistencias ..1973/74 ... " 13 assistencias também "


    ...bem

    Acredito ..

    que Gerd Muller e Franz Beckenbauer estão empatados ...na Historia do Futebol Alemão ... !
     
  5. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    .....









    Gerd Muller decide the bigger Matches .. almost Always !
     
  6. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024



    ....

    .
    My Point...is:


    BORN DECISION MAKING POWER... on the biggest Matches... is the most important thing for me...




    YOU CAN'T LEARN THAT, YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT..!



    AND

    STRONGER PERSONALITY ARE NOT FOR SALE ..ON THE SQUARE !



    "YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT.. !"



    If YOU DON'T HAVE IT .. !


    becomes like a Ronaldinho..Gaucho of life... Lots of Talent in Skills.. in the Skills part....


    But at the time of the Decision...of the Big Game...

    He decides practically nothing for himself.. in his Career..

    It needs Belletti... Larsson..Eto'o... Rivaldo.. Ronaldo Nazario..
    to decide for him...

    ..I'm not saying that it was the same case as Franz Beckenbauer...

    Beckenbauer... gave a lot of assists... and pre_assists... in the matches I saw him playing...


    But I'm..meaning that Gerd Muller is highly underrated as hell...


    Gerd Muller in 1970-71... was the Assists leader.." 13 "..of the Bundesliga...

    for example..stayed..ahead..of Beckenbauer..Overath..Netzer...etc..



    Franz Beckenbauer was the leader in assists..1973/74... "13 assists too"


    ...good

    I believe ..

    that Gerd Muller and Franz Beckenbauer are tied...in German Football History...!
     
  7. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024

    ...
     
  8. Trachta10

    Trachta10 Member+

    Apr 25, 2016
    Club:
    CA Boca Juniors
    If we talk about the general public's perception, without a doubt, if Gerd Muller played today, he would be regarded as one of the best in the world by fans, because the analysis done nowadays is 'more goals = better player.'
    However, in the past, for some reason (which I believe is correct), journalists didn’t value goal scorers as much. Perhaps because there were more goals, the perceived value of an individual goal was lower. In general, creative, intelligent players who worked for the team were valued much more.
    I’ve seen this a lot, for example, in how the press highly valued Di Stéfano for how he dropped back and guided the team, or how Didi was chosen as the best player of the 1958 World Cup, even though there were players who 'scored' more goals.
    Or for instance, today people talk about Josef Bican, but back then, no one considered him even close to being the best in the world. So, it makes a lot of sense that the press of that era considered Beckenbauer to be much better than Gerd Muller
     
    Wiliam Felipe Gracek repped this.
  9. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024

    i guess ... that you are underRated too much Gerd Muller ... right now ..

    Gerd Muller in 1970-71... was the Assists leader.." 13 "..of the Bundesliga...

    for example..stayed..ahead..of Beckenbauer..Overath..Netzer...etc..



    Franz Beckenbauer was the leader in assists..1973/74... "13 assists too"


    ...good

    I believe ..

    that Gerd Muller and Franz Beckenbauer are tied...in German Football History...!





    Gerd Muller .. in the game against Real Madrid 1976 ...


    he tackles Won already in the Start of the match ..


    Plays one-twos ...
    short passes in speed all the time with too much accuracy ..%



    Gerd Muller .;;

    did one Defensive Cover and Interception ... Incredible against Real Madrid in 1976 !
     
  10. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    ...






    ...
     
  11. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024

    ...My Point...is:


    BORN DECISION MAKING POWER... on the biggest Matches... is the most important thing for me...




    YOU CAN'T LEARN THAT, YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT..!



    AND

    STRONGER PERSONALITY ARE NOT FOR SALE ..ON THE SQUARE !



    "YOU EITHER HAVE IT OR YOU DON'T HAVE IT.. !"

    The Own Beckenbauer says it ;;;,,,,,,as well !!!

    If YOU DON'T HAVE IT .. !


    becomes like a Ronaldinho..Gaucho of life... Lots of Talent in Skills.. in the Skills part....


    But at the time of the Decision...of the Big Game...

    He decides practically nothing for himself.. in his Career..

    It needs Belletti... Larsson..Eto'o... Rivaldo.. Ronaldo Nazario..
    to decide for him...

    ..I'm not saying that it was the same case as Franz Beckenbauer...

    Beckenbauer... gave a lot of assists... and pre_assists... in the matches I saw him playing...


    But I'm..meaning that Gerd Muller is highly underrated as hell...


    Gerd Muller in 1970-71... was the Assists leader.." 13 "..of the Bundesliga...

    for example..stayed..ahead..of Beckenbauer..Overath..Netzer...etc..



    Franz Beckenbauer was the leader in assists..1973/74... "13 assists too"


    ...good

    I believe ..

    that Gerd Muller and Franz Beckenbauer are tied...in German Football History...!
     
  12. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024

    yes ... Didi ...and Di Stefano ;;;; were Genius ...


    But Total Footballers at the same time ...


    Despite ;; abit the Slow Didi ..sometimes ..

    but He has super Vision on the whole Field ..... ...Long Range Pass .... Swerve ...curve ... to surpass

    the him Slowly mode .. sometimes ... and good Pace ..!
     
  13. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    How many Whole matches ... that you saw of Gerd Muller until now ???


    give me Details about it ???


    you can do this ???
     
  14. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    ... upload_2024-9-30_3-21-12.png
     
  15. Letmepost

    Letmepost Member

    Arsenal
    South Korea
    Apr 11, 2023
    #1966 Letmepost, Sep 30, 2024 at 2:46 AM
    Last edited: Sep 30, 2024 at 2:51 AM
    From what very little I've watched (I have yet to complete a full game of Gerd Muller, before losing my focus, I can maybe last 30 minutes on a good day), I feel like some people are overly-devaluing Gerd Muller for his mediocre progressive ability with the ball at his feet (in terms of dribbling and progressive passing), which is parallel to the type of analyzing (in my opinion) that results in Uli Hoeneß being rated higher in terms of Kicker ratings. I really don't like players being ranked by their progressive ability with the ball at their feet only.

    I think Gerd Muller wasn't just another positionally aware poacher who can be marked out of a game with tight enough marking, he had an element of unstoppable nature to his game. I think this is the key distinction. He literally was almost impossible to prevent from scoring, which cannot be said for a lot of brilliant goal-scorers.

    He could receive the ball in difficult scenarios, but with his quick thinking, good strength with the goal behind his back, fast turn rate without losing balance, really good flexibility and ability to hoodwink his markers to wrong-foot them to suddenly open up shooting angles, could combine these traits to score at the blink of an eye, that looked close to superhuman to my eyes.

    A lot of players have hesitation, or even over-complication with impressive but unecesssary touches of the ball, but Gerd Muller had brevity. There is an art to that. You don't need to make goal-scoring aesthetically pleasing to be functionally superlative. Let the Puskas Awards handle that topic.
     
    Wiliam Felipe Gracek repped this.
  16. Wiliam Felipe Gracek

    Santos FC
    France
    Feb 3, 2024


    Great Comment !!... Great Vision at all !

    i have the same feeling on Gerd Muller .. !

    Der Bomber from Nation ! " Germany "


    ..Plays one-Twos .. faster too !!
     

Share This Page